★★★★★
Repeat
I've gotten the same "happy birthday" topper two months in a row. Disappointed.
Mystery Topper Surprise
🎁 Surprise Pack
One-of-a-Kind Designs, Made for YOU
Fresh designs ship in 3-5 days. Never duplicates — buy unlimited packs!
6 Unique Designs
Ships in 2-3 Days
Perfect Gift
Choose Your Pack Size
✨ Fresh designs every month
🚫 Never the same design twice
⏸️ Skip or cancel anytime
Made JUST for You
Every design is created uniquely for YOUR order — no one else will ever have these exact designs.
Ships in 3-5 days
100% unique to you
Never duplicates — ever
Buy unlimited packs
Your pack includes:
🌟 Evergreen favorites
🍂 Current season vibes
🎄 Upcoming holiday sneak peeks
Workplace-friendly humor that sparks conversations!
Popular themes:
$14.99 • Ships worldwide 🌎
🎁 Surprise Pack • 6 Designs
$14.99
Our collection of exclusive mystery toppers is continuously growing.
Add this to receive 1 randomly selected mystery topper now!
Product Details:
- 1 brand-new, individually wrapped topper that is randomly selected, and a total surPRIZE!
- Fun, Inspiring, Beautiful, Hilarious, Exclusive Designs that will NEVER be available for purchase
- The thrill of discovering your mystery toppers one-by-one as you tear open each individual protective sleeve.
- Your Treasure Your Way-order when you please to draw a new mystery topper, or subscribe for a great discount to receive a new mystery topper automatically each month. (hint: you can buy more than 1 to score more mystery toppers!
Unique
Our Design Crew is dedicated to creating the most awesome, fun, inspiring, and beautiful designs--available to Treasure Seekers only!
Full Details
Our new mystery topper goes beyond a badge reel. It immerses you in an experience like no other.
When you receive a mystery topper in the mail, you'll feel the thrill of excitement and wonder. It’s like going on a treasure hunt, only this time you are guaranteed to find the treasure.
Something new awaits you every time, with that individual packet ready to be opened --it will feel like Christmas!
Get your mystery topper today and uncover the magic. Good luck!
Unlock VIP
Choose the Subscribe & Save option to automatically gain VIP access. This means 20% OFF sitewide, FREE shipping on all orders, and access to the limited edition holiday vault (all previous holiday designs).
Mystery Topper Surprise
Sale price$ 5.00
4.1
★★★★★
8 verified reviews
What badge-wearers are saying
Real reviews from thousands of real badge-wearers.
★★★★★
Mystery toppers
I have had an addiction to these toppers for some time. I think I have over 100 of them and can almost wear a different one every day of the year without repeating. The monthly mystery topper has been my favorite “subscription”! Most months it’s absolutely adorable! I think I have only gotten one duplicate so far! Love love love Topperswap
★★★★★
Can't stop subscription
Having great difficulty stopping this subscription. I Ling ago lost my badge reel and can't get this subscription to be cancelled. Maybe a poor review will help someone get in touch with me.
★★★★★
It was nice to recieve one a month, but the magnet part of the holder never held up
★★★★★
Never received
I never received a mystery topper.
★★★★★
Fair
Was good over all. The top fell ofd alot when I had 2 decor behind the cover. The decor sometimes bends.
★★★★★
Mystery topper
Love opening my mystery toppers each month. They are are always so cute! Wish could upgrade to every 2 weeks.
★★★★★
Love it!